What was this from, a television episode or play? Neither of the two made any movie together nor one called "An Eye For An Eye".
from a t.v.show
I read the detailed review. Interesting story, and a fair cast. Milland's character is "Ray Markham" a detective. This episode of the anthology series "Suspense" came out in 1958. The following year Milland did his second series "Markham" where his character was a combination of detective and lawyer. Maybe this was originally his series' pilot episode. The new series (which Milland said he loathed) lasted from 1959 to 1960.